Cheshire West is overruled: review every DoLS you hold
The Supreme Court has overruled its own 2014 decision and scrapped the acid test, and DHSC says cases should be reviewed as soon as is practicable.
Since 31 March 2026 every care home resident in Scotland can name an Essential Care Supporter, and suspending one now carries a legal presumption of serious harm.
Every resident in a Scottish care home must be able to name at least one Essential Care Supporter, and that person's access is now protected in law rather than by policy. If your visiting policy still reads as something you grant, it needs rewriting. The regulations came into force on 31 March 2026.
The Care Home Services (Visits to and by Care Home Residents) (Scotland) Regulations 2026, SSI 2026/166, were made on 18 March 2026 and came into force on 31 March 2026. They are made under the Care Reform (Scotland) Act 2025 and are the delivery vehicle for what the sector has called Anne's Law. The full text is on legislation.gov.uk.
Three things follow directly.
First, each resident is entitled to at least one named Essential Care Supporter. This is not a visitor in the old sense. It is a named person with a recognised role in the resident's care and wellbeing.
Second, the entitlement covers visits in and visits out. A resident going out with their Essential Care Supporter is part of the same protected relationship, not a separate favour requiring separate justification.
Third, suspension is exceptional. You may only suspend where there is reasonable cause to believe suspension is essential to prevent a serious risk. That is a high threshold and it is worded to be one.
A suspension is reviewable on written request. It must be notified to the Care Inspectorate and to the local authority Chief Social Work Officer. In other words, a decision that used to sit inside a home's own management now travels outward to two external bodies on the day you make it.
The accompanying code of practice, published on 23 March 2026, goes further. It creates a legal presumption that suspending an Essential Care Supporter causes serious harm. Read that carefully. The starting point is that your action harms the resident, and the burden sits with you to show the risk you were preventing was greater. The code is published by the Scottish Government.
The cultural shift matters more than the paperwork. The regulations move the default from restrict-then-justify to permit-unless-justified, and inspection will follow the default.
SSI 2026/166 on legislation.gov.uk and the Anne's Law code of practice published by the Scottish Government.
The regulations require at least one named Essential Care Supporter per resident, so one is the floor rather than the ceiling. Record who has been named, and make sure the nomination reflects the resident's own wishes wherever they can express them, involving their representative where they cannot.
You need reasonable cause to believe the suspension is essential to prevent a serious risk. The suspension is reviewable on written request, and it must be notified to the Care Inspectorate and to the local authority Chief Social Work Officer. The code of practice presumes suspension causes serious harm, so record your reasoning fully.
Yes. The regulations cover visits to and by care home residents, meaning visits out as well as visits in. Treating an outing as a separate discretionary decision, subject to a different approval route, does not sit well with the entitlement or with the code of practice behind it.
How this was written. Care Shield’s press desk drafts from primary sources — the statute book, regulator publications and government announcements — and publishes automatically once every factual claim traces to a named source. The sources are listed above so you can check them. It is not legal advice, and it is not a substitute for reading the regulation that applies to your service. If you find something wrong, tell us at hello@careshieldcompliance.co.uk and we will correct it in public, on this page.
What changed, what it means operationally, and what you have to do about it — across CQC, the Care Inspectorate, CIW and RQIA. Written by our press desk, sourced from the statute book and the regulators themselves.
One email a week. We send it from news.careshieldcompliance.co.uk, you can unsubscribe from the bottom of any issue in one click, and we will never pass your address to anyone. What we do with it is set out in our privacy policy.The Supreme Court has overruled its own 2014 decision and scrapped the acid test, and DHSC says cases should be reviewed as soon as is practicable.
From 1 August 2026 the Scottish Government covers PVG costs for eligible new social care posts, saving £18 or £59 per check if you use the right prefix.
The ICO says it will prioritise enforcement against persistent subject access delays, after a pilot found people waiting up to 16 years for records.